My one contribution to the Goncharov Phenomena is, I’ve seen people comment on how Tumblr only managed to have a nuanced conversation about a piece of media when the piece of media doesn’t exist, but…
I can’t help but think. It just isn’t the same people.
The people who bother to make memes examining the complexity of Goncharov are the same people who enjoy examining the complexity of actual media, who have been here doing that forever, who already knew how to handle a subtle take.
It’s just that the people who would usually come crashing in and derail the whole thing aren’t saying anything, because, well, faking nuanced interpretation is fun for its own sake, but faking moral outrage isn’t.
I don’t think it’s so much that Tumblr finally learned how to handle a nuanced take, I think it’s more that the fakeness of Goncharov automatically filters out people who can’t
Oh 2002-era songfics with lyrics interspersed between paragraphs, my deceased beloved.
Wait those are dead? I still write those on occasion
You’re a saint who has transcended the passage of time. We don’t deserve you. 🙏🙏🙏
But yeah for the most part they died out because FFnet literally banned them over “copyright” issues, and this was years and years before AO3 existed, so there was not really anywhere “legal” to post them, and they fell out of fashion.
Glee literally had an offline con for one f/f ship. When canon provides, by and large, fans will respond.
People are terrible about going “But I love my blorbo! Surely, everyone else should!” in contexts where basic logic will tell you that ship or character is probably not going to launch a juggernaut fandom.