🔹 Someone else’s fiction cannot cause you physical harm.
🔹If someone else’s fiction is causing you emotional or psychological harm, or distress, you can put it down and not read/watch it.
🔹Your emotional well-being is not the responsibility of fiction writers.
🔹Someone else’s fiction is not about your personal trauma.
🔹When reading or watching fiction, you always have the power. You can always stop. You are never reading fiction without your own consent.
🔹Fiction writers are not responsible for other people’s mental health.
🔹The content of a piece of fiction does not reflect on the morality of its author.
🔹Just because someone writes about bad things happening, doesn’t mean they want those things to happen.
🔹Don’t like? Don’t read.
“The content of a piece of fiction does not reflect on the morality of its author.”
Allow me to be clearer, because I think you misunderstand.
Your personal interpretation of the content of a piece of fiction does not reflect on the morality of it’s author.
You have to understand that you’re, lowkey, being dismissive.
Every interpretation of a story is- personal. You aren’t gonna interpret the entire story the exact same way your friends interpret it or even the author itself. Our interpretation is entirely based on personal feelings, knowledge, experience, etc. It’s an inherently subjective process.
Though, that doesn’t magically mean our interpretation of things are inherently false, kind of like how you shouldn’t just dismiss people that think the Earth is flat or Pluto is a planet. You should be asking, “Why? Why do you think the Earth is flat? Why do you think Pluto is a planet? Why do you think [random author goes here] is a bad person? What evidence do have that supports this?”
Media literacy is gonna stay low if we can’t bring ourselves to have more constructive discussions.
I feel like we have some kind of miscommunication or disconnect of meaning here.
Because I agree with you that every interpretation of a story is personal.
Which is exactly why we can’t draw any conclusions about an author’s morality based solely on the content of their writing and our interpretation of it.
There was a post going around recently where someone had misinterpreted Miyazaki’s anti-fascist work to believe that he was pro-fascist.
A person can’t go around assuming that an author believes in immoral ideas just because the characters in their fiction act in immoral ways.
But, they can. They can go around assuming an author believes in immoral ideas simply because the characters in their stories act in immoral ways. That have the right to do that, and should have the right to do.
The way to address that kind of problem is not the spreading absurd lie that “…we can’t draw any conclusions about an author’s morality based solely on the content of their writing and our interpretation of it.” As a writer myself, I just think it’s an unreasonably defensive position to take.
A much better solution would be talking to these people, challenging them and making them defend their positions. Making them explain themselves, and support themselves with evidence. At the same time, providing evidence as to why what they believe is wrong.
The shape of the Earth has been questioned and discussed so much that it is easily one of the most well supported scientific theories out there. In other words, we should see people misinterpreting Miyazaki’s work as opportunities to grow ourselves and help others grow. You have every right to be annoyed and frustrated, but at the end of the day, the best weapon against misinformation and disinformation, is true information.
I am gonna assume you’re not trying to insult me, but understand that I’m a little pissed, so I’m gonna swear more than usual:
I’m literally telling you, “Hey, proving these people wrong would be more effective than telling them what they can and can’t do,” and you’re response is “How would they know anything about the author?”
I don’t fucking know! I don’t fucking care! I wish you would fucking listen to me and realize I’m trying to help you address the very problem you’re talking about in a genuinely productive manner.
As far as I can tell, you’re trying to address the problem of people incorrectly interpreting a work of fiction.
I’m trying to address the problem of judgemental assholes who believe in thought-crime thinking it’s okay to automatically assume that people who write or read about child abuse are child abusers.
But maybe I’m interpreting you incorrectly. That would be pretty hilarious given our conversation.
If you can enjoy a character who is insane, violent, murderous, manipulative, and genocidal, but freak out at the idea that the same character might be sexually interested in adult but younger women, maybe you should
a) reconsider why your moral framework works that way
b) find a new character to like.
this#stop acting like sex or sexual interests are somehow worse than violence#literally stop acting like anything sexual is worse than violence
LOUDER THANK YOU!! <3
(Also stop acting like the problem with actual real life sexual violence is the sex part and not the violence part. This not only informs pro-censorship and pro-harassment attitudes towards fiction and people engaging with sexual content in fiction, but hurts survivors and in many cases actively perpetuates rape culture.)
🔹 Someone else’s fiction cannot cause you physical harm.
🔹If someone else’s fiction is causing you emotional or psychological harm, or distress, you can put it down and not read/watch it.
🔹Your emotional well-being is not the responsibility of fiction writers.
🔹Someone else’s fiction is not about your personal trauma.
🔹When reading or watching fiction, you always have the power. You can always stop. You are never reading fiction without your own consent.
🔹Fiction writers are not responsible for other people’s mental health.
🔹The content of a piece of fiction does not reflect on the morality of its author.
🔹Just because someone writes about bad things happening, doesn’t mean they want those things to happen.
🔹Don’t like? Don’t read.
“The content of a piece of fiction does not reflect on the morality of its author.”
Allow me to be clearer, because I think you misunderstand.
Your personal interpretation of the content of a piece of fiction does not reflect on the morality of it’s author.
Also on the website infamous for the worst most bad faith media takes not even god could condone I don’t think we should be taking others word on an authors morality based in their text
I’ve described this website’s relationship with media interpretation as “beating the author’s corpse”#where they’ll claim death of the author to defend a blatantly bad faith interpretation#then use that interpretation to call the author a fascist
🔹 Someone else’s fiction cannot cause you physical harm.
🔹If someone else’s fiction is causing you emotional or psychological harm, or distress, you can put it down and not read/watch it.
🔹Your emotional well-being is not the responsibility of fiction writers.
🔹Someone else’s fiction is not about your personal trauma.
🔹When reading or watching fiction, you always have the power. You can always stop. You are never reading fiction without your own consent.
🔹Fiction writers are not responsible for other people’s mental health.
🔹The content of a piece of fiction does not reflect on the morality of its author.
🔹Just because someone writes about bad things happening, doesn’t mean they want those things to happen.
🔹Don’t like? Don’t read.
“The content of a piece of fiction does not reflect on the morality of its author.”
Allow me to be clearer, because I think you misunderstand.
Your personal interpretation of the content of a piece of fiction does not reflect on the morality of it’s author.
You have to understand that you’re, lowkey, being dismissive.
Every interpretation of a story is- personal. You aren’t gonna interpret the entire story the exact same way your friends interpret it or even the author itself. Our interpretation is entirely based on personal feelings, knowledge, experience, etc. It’s an inherently subjective process.
Though, that doesn’t magically mean our interpretation of things are inherently false, kind of like how you shouldn’t just dismiss people that think the Earth is flat or Pluto is a planet. You should be asking, “Why? Why do you think the Earth is flat? Why do you think Pluto is a planet? Why do you think [random author goes here] is a bad person? What evidence do have that supports this?”
Media literacy is gonna stay low if we can’t bring ourselves to have more constructive discussions.
I feel like we have some kind of miscommunication or disconnect of meaning here.
Because I agree with you that every interpretation of a story is personal.
Which is exactly why we can’t draw any conclusions about an author’s morality based solely on the content of their writing and our interpretation of it.
There was a post going around recently where someone had misinterpreted Miyazaki’s anti-fascist work to believe that he was pro-fascist.
A person can’t go around assuming that an author believes in immoral ideas just because the characters in their fiction act in immoral ways.
But, they can. They can go around assuming an author believes in immoral ideas simply because the characters in their stories act in immoral ways. That have the right to do that, and should have the right to do.
The way to address that kind of problem is not the spreading absurd lie that “…we can’t draw any conclusions about an author’s morality based solely on the content of their writing and our interpretation of it.” As a writer myself, I just think it’s an unreasonably defensive position to take.
A much better solution would be talking to these people, challenging them and making them defend their positions. Making them explain themselves, and support themselves with evidence. At the same time, providing evidence as to why what they believe is wrong.
The shape of the Earth has been questioned and discussed so much that it is easily one of the most well supported scientific theories out there. In other words, we should see people misinterpreting Miyazaki’s work as opportunities to grow ourselves and help others grow. You have every right to be annoyed and frustrated, but at the end of the day, the best weapon against misinformation and disinformation, is true information.
I haven’t seen someone articulate their position that fictional stories and misinformation are the same thing this well in quite some time.
The new GTA 6 teaser had over 100 million views in three days. We’re going to sit there for a while to question everyone who wants to buy that game why they believe that armed robbery and vehicular homicide are good and worthwhile pastimes to have.