The best way to make them stop is to ignore them or laugh at them… even if that’s not how you feel on the inside.
Joke’s on them: they’re giving you free advertising.
It is actually pretty common, or it used to be. AO3’s culture is not like this for the most part, but the 00s were rife with “sporking” accounts, and there used to be whole communities of twits on FFN who would rip apart fic for being “OOC” when what they actually meant was “gay” and/or “horny”.
It’s a common pastime of the emotionally immature. They especially love inexperienced writers who are easy to cow. Don’t give them the satisfaction.
As for the comments, delete the obnoxious ones. People like seeing their own stupid opinions, and people like joining dogpiles. If their stuff is deleted, it won’t attract as many new people. If you moderate comments, they can’t automatically get the thrill of seeing their nonsense out there.
I personally prefer to archive-lock all my work unless it’s a recent exchange fic or something. That cuts down on drive-by morons.
#flames will be used to roast marshmallows#i’m sorry you’re having to deal with this anon
*cackling*
Anon, if you’re not seeing the tags on this post, more than one person has responded with something like this.
Stupid open trolling of the “Ur fic sucks!!!” variety used to be extremely common to the point where there are all these cliched author’s notes we used to see about it—primarily “Flames will be used to ___”.
Is answering comments on AO3 a no-go because it alters your comments-count?
Okay, so I got a question. I started uploading my art also on AO3, mostly because there will be NSWF stuff which I can’t upload here.
Now I do get a lot of so nice and friendly comments, it’s awesome. BUT: Do I answer them? Normally I’d answer every single one with a “Thank you” at least, but I’m hesitating. Because that would alter my comment-count, which is a sorting possibility on AO3. Would it look as if I’d try to up that number?
I especially wonder because I see a lot of fresh works, where the authors do not answer the short comments like “Nice, Loved that, etc.”
I absolutely don’t have a clue what the etiquette is here, maybe someone can help? And if you don’t mind, maybe some reblogs for wider audience, because I’m pretty new with only a few followers (and I LOVE every single one of you!)
What I know is that commenters LOVE it when the author replies to their comment, and it encourages more comments in the future!
Comments are music to my heart. I would reply regardless of what it did to AO3 or their algo. It meant so much to me when total strangers loved my story so much that they wrote to tell me just that.
Just….that.
And don’t even get me started on the ones who wrote to tell me WHAT they loved. Oh gracious.
So yes, answer the comments if you can. You….don’t have to. I mean, I’ve written a great many comments on stories and never heard a peep in response and that is okay too! But…. @blackheartbiohazards is right–it’s a unique joy when an author takes time to write back. Even if all they say is “thank you” or “you’re welcome.” One feels….rather loved and seen on both sides of that conversation. <3
I’ve been on both sides. I comment on most of the fics I’ve read. I also answer the comments I’ve received. The only one I haven’t is because we had been dming about it.