I often see posts about curating your own online experience that make the point, “content creators aren’t your parents.” And, yes, that is absolutely true! And I try not to be like “as a parent,“ but as a parent…
EVEN PARENTS ARE SUPPOSED TO ENCOURAGE RESPONSIBLE READING/VIEWING BEHAVIOR. NOT filter everything ahead of time for their kid.
When my kiddo was 5, his pediatrician was asking him the usual Well Child Visit questions (“What are your favorite foods? What do you do to get your body moving? Do you know what to do if you get lost in a public place?” Etc.) and she asked, “What do you do if you see something on TV that scares or upsets you?”
I piped up like, “Oh, he doesn’t watch TV without one of us in the room,” which was true at the time and is still largely true now. She said, “Yes, but that won’t always be the case, so make sure you’re talking to him about what to do if he sees something that upsets him.”
So we started talking to him about that, and the answer is simple: “Turn it off or leave the room, and talk to someone you trust about what you saw and what you’re feeling.”
The answer is NOT “Ask your parents to make sure you never see anything upsetting again,” because that’s just not possible — and ultimately that would be doing the kid a disservice, since sooner or later he’s going to be out in the world where we can’t control what he watches or reads. That doesn’t mean we don’t try to make sure he’s watching/reading age-appropriate stuff, it just means that’s not the only safeguard he has — and that’s a good thing.
So yes, content creators aren’t your parents and aren’t responsible for making sure you never see anything you don’t like — but also, your own parents should have taught you what to do when that happens. So if they didn’t, take it from me, your internet mom:
Turn it off.
Walk away.
Talk to someone you trust about how you’re feeling.
And leave the person who created the thing that upset you alone.
When my oldest kids were small – about 6 and 8 – I bought them a Video (the VCR kind) of John Waters’ Hairspray, a film they loved, and, getting home at 3 am, left it for them with a note. They woke me up the next morning. “It’s not Hairspray. It’s something scary with a car.” Due to a mislabelling error, the videotape was Stephen King’s Christine.
I mentioned it to friends and a day later got a call from a tabloid journalist who wanted to know about this terrible thing that had happened to my family. “It’s not a story, ” I told them. “My kids know where the off-button is and how to press it, and the moment they knew they weren’t watching what they wanted to watch, they turned it off.”
The stigma of self-inserts is so harmful to the creative process. Relax. Admit it. Everything you make is derivative of yourself, always, no exceptions. You can turn the mirror into tinier and tinier shards or you can make it as big as you want to reflect as much as you want. At the end of the day it’s always going to show you inside of it. Pretending otherwise is stupid.
It’s not about not using self-inserts.
It’s about doing it in a way so that the reader doesn’t know.
If I read the book and come to a moment where “oh, this is the author writing about themselves” my interest in the story drops by about 300%. Don’t make it obvious and you’ll be fine.
Nope. Wrong. Missed the point. It’s about using self-inserts. You can make it as obvious as you want. It’s perfectly fine. The point is to have fun.
THIS IS ABOUT SELF-INSERTS NOT READER-INSERTS (I misread initially)
Self-inserts! Do them! I won’t read em but do em anyways! You’re not supposed to appeal to me!!!
Reader-inserts, however. I am not a fan (evil)
“You’re not supposed to appeal to me!!! But also if you write reader-inserts I am judging you”
Nope. You’re missing the point also. Reader-inserts are also cool and chill. It isn’t fucking about appealing to you.
As long as they aren’t Mary Sues and clay the best, most coolest person ever who never does anything wrong.
Those characters are lame, let me see then walk into a light pole or get caught acting like a dweeb.
Nope. You’re missing the point still. Stop acting like it’s acceptable behavior for you to call the earnest creation of art “lame”. Power fantasy characters are rad as fuck. Everybody loves seeing John Wick do that shit. You’re not just being needlessly rude and harmful to others, you’re also just flat out fuckin wrong.