“why would you write fics for small, unpopular fandoms? you’re not gonna reach that many hits in fandoms not many people know about” ?? because I’m not writing fics for hits or kudos, I’m writing them for me because these characters are my blorbos and I have so many ideas, so much thoughts about them that my brain might explode if I don’t write them out.
Ah. You’re still thinking about that tag in a more cultural sense, but that’s not what it’s for. If you dig through the FAQs and such, the explanation is in there somewhere, but to summarize, it refers to:
On page depictions of sexual activity including at least one character under 18.
(So if they just kiss or you just say she had sex but you don’t show intercourse, oral, etc. on the actual page, it doesn’t count.)
AO3’s underage tag is actually to protect users who live in jurisdictions where <18 sexytimes are banned from art or banned unless there’s ~artistic merit~ or whatever. Around the time AO3 was starting up was when Australia was having a big upheaval over such things, so it was on people’s minds in the Anglosphere.
Whether the sex is problematique or age gap or whatever doesn’t matter. The actual age of consent or laws around sex in the real world location these characters are in, if any, does not matter. Your 17-year-old UK characters fucking still need the warning or CNTW even though that’s laughable in context. 18 tends to be the age most used in international law for… like… porn star ages and such, so 18 is what AO3 went with. Never mind that it’s not necessarily the age of majority or that age of consent laws can depend on partner age, etc. etc.
Unlike noncon/graphic violence/character death, this warning isn’t there primarily because readers find the topic squicky.
I see graff off the side of those highway bridge things with death drops below and im just. in awe. death machines on one side, death by gravity on the other; and somehow, rushing through the thin space between life and death, is a talented and very brave artist who not only managed to get to that place but also to stay there all the long while and make art there. i have off the charts respect for graff artists. no fucking idea how they manage some of the shit they do.