a fandom old’s guide to how livejournal fandom worked (in super basic terms)
so people are talking about dreamwidth as a tumblr alternative, and the idea of a return to livejournal-style fandom is sort of exciting to old people like me. but it is also wildly, unthinkably different from tumblr and twitter fandoms, not just in user experience but in the actual fundamentals of fandom activity itself. so i thought i’d try to explain how livejournal fandoms worked!
your journal
the obvious comparison here is your tumblr blog! but there’s a reason sites like tumblr were called “microblogging”: the DW/LJ style journal is much more text-heavy. there’s no mechanism for reblogging, and posting standalone images without a caption or story to go with it was not the norm. this is because most of the time when you’re posting, you’re hoping to actually start a conversation in the comments!
unlike on tumblr, comments were actually useful and useable. they nest, so it’s super clear who is responding to whom, and you can have multiple threads of conversation in response to a single post. i’d argue this is where the core of fandom interactions took place!
some people made their journals entirely private, meaning you have to be mutuals or added as a follower to see their stuff. this made it much, much easier to curate your fandom experience by being able to post meta/thoughts/complaints just to a selected circle of followers and friends.
the posts of journals you follow show up on a feed just like your tumblr dash, in reverse chronological order. as I said, there is no ay to share a post on your feed, just comment on it or write your own post and link to it. random discoverability is… low. there are tags, but they are only used for searching within someone’s journal.
so how do you find people, or get to know someone who has a private journal? well–
cohost is a lot like tumblr. you can have a blog, you can reblog things.
cohost is also a lot NOT like tumblr. it’s explicitly anti-algorithm, no ads, and extremely transparent.
it’s made by some friends of mine, and right now it’s invite-only, but you can also make an account and you’re put into a queue that’s activated as the site scales up. I think it’s a really cool project and I’m going to be on there more and more, i think.
it’s totally free, and the culture is still starting, but there is some real top-tier Posting going on. you can check out the cohost twitter account for more information, but i really think this is gonna Be Something.
if we’re mutuals feel free to reach out for an invite code, i have a few more saved up.(update signup is totally open now) the site’s good, i love it, and i’m way less worried about some of the dumb shit that circles around sites like tumblr or twitter. for one thing, they’re actively doing all these things:
i trust these folks, and i think the site’s good. i think more people should be on it, and if you’re used to tumblr you’ll probably like cohost.
Reblogging this again to add things I’ve liked while splorin co-host:
You can add private notes about a user on their profile (only visible to yourself) which I’ve always wanted so I leave myself a reminder for “artist draws x character the way i like” or “blocked this guy for being a creep”
Marking content warnings are streamlined and collective so you dont have to filter out 50 versions of the same way to tag it (#tw, #cw, #cw:, etc)
It looks like they just took all the things people generally like from Tumblr and Twitter and built on it.
I like that “reblogs/retweets” are “shares”
And i also like that theres a waiting period after signing up to be able to post, but still lets me explore tags, functions, edit, etc. Like introducing a new cat
Asks, anons, replies are all there
Pinned tags to your profile for easy art tag or themed post organization
Other features i liked but cant think of at the moment
Tldr; hope it grows, it reminds me of a simplified tumblr from when i was younger in a good way
So because cohost does not have an algorithm you have to actively lookfor things and I wrote a post about how that makes me feel :)))