“The intention” is not for it to apply to ONLY ‘extreme underage’. This is literally what the site itself defines as Underage (see the question mark on ‘Archive Warnings’ when you are posting a new work):
This is for descriptions or depictions of sexual activity by characters under the age of eighteen. (This doesn’t include dating activity like kissing or vague references with no actual description or depiction.) This warning generally applies to humans; if you are creating a pornographic work about space aliens who only live for a month or thousand-year-old vampires with twelve-year-old bodies, please just use your best judgment. You are always free to specify characters’ ages or to use “Choose Not to Use Archive Warnings”.
It says “characters under the age of eighteen”. Not “characters who are/look prebubescent”. If I’m not mistaken, I’ve seen @/olderthannetfic say this warning was made like this exactly because of countries where porn of fictional minors is illegal (such as Australia) and so users from those countries can be sure of what risk they are taking when going into specific works.
If you want to avoid stuff like loli/shota or other ‘extreme underage’ stuff… You are gonna have to filter out the ‘extreme uderage’, ‘shotacon’ and ‘lolicon’ tags. And probably pay extra attention to the other additional tags. Plus rely on your own knowledge of canon. (As an example: if an explicit Black Butler fic involving Ciel DOESN’T have an “aged-up character(s)” tag, it’s probably safe to assume it is shotacon.)
But no, the ‘Underage’ warning is not being ‘watered down’. This is exactly what it is meant to warn for.
One thing (and trust me, theres more) i hate about antis is their hypocrisy towards different crimes
“You can’t ship that! It’s illegal!!” Yeah and the guy who murders people is also illegal, but youre fine with shipping him with people.
“You can’t like that character! They canonically sexually assaulted someone!” But you love that one character who physically assaults people?
I don’t get why antis thing sexual crimes are the worst of the worst and if you even tolerate a character who did that, you deserve to get death threats. And the fact that they hate abusive ships so badly, but love characters who are murderers? That’s just double standards, and I’m tired of it.
If one immoral crime is okay in fiction, then they all should be. No crime is above or below other crimes. They’re all horrible actions that can traumatize someone for life, but since its fictional and not real, all of them should be okay to engage in, IN FICTION. Because it isn’t real.
“But sexual, abuse, and pedophilic crimes can trigger someone! That’s why we cant have them!” You ever thought that maybe murder and assault could trigger someone? There’s a lot of people who are triggered by gore, and yet I don’t see any antis sending death threats to those who make it. And guess what? Tagging exists. You can filter out tags so that you don’t have to see any of that. That’s why tagging posts is so important, so that people who have triggers related to that content won’t be able to see it. Problem solved, and everyone gets to do what they want.
But antis just don’t want to do that? They’d rather shame people for liking immoral things, or not even just immoral, things THEY classify as more immoral than other immoral things.
It seriously makes no sense, and I can’t grasp how antis think like this.
When people– and especially young women– are attracted to “abusive” and “controlling” and “violent” male characters in fiction–
The fantasy is not about being abused, or controlled.
The fantasy is about a partner who is devoted to you, who takes care of you, who will defend you, to a larger than life degree.
And because it’s fantasy, the person doing the fantasizing is in control.
The person having the fantasy knows for sure that when her fictional man says “I’m doing this because I love you” it’s true, and not an excuse for abuse.
Because it’s a fantasy. It’s a story.
“Abusive” romantic leads in stories don’t lead to women dating abusers any more than stories about unicorns lead to people buying horses.
Yandere?
What you’re describing is basically a yandere romance fantasy, and it’s far from something that only young women have had.
I don’t think the post is saying that only young women are into this trope. I think that part meant to point out how it’s mostly young women who get shit on and are assumed to be stupid for enjoying the trope.