I want to make a rebloggable version of this thought since I had this happen last night and this morning on the same artwork, on a different artwork last week, and in general it’s something I have to deal with more often than I’d like.
If you have an issue with a character or a ship, for fucks sake, don’t air out those grievances on someone’s creative work!!
It’s fine to not like something, but it’s really hurtful to leave a reply or tag it, or as was the case these last two times, put your opinions in the body of the post underneath the artwork. The artist or writer or gif maker can see that!! It sucks!! It’s hurtful! And especially if you put it in the post itself it can potentially generate a discussion about criticizing the character or ship on what was otherwise a post celebrating it.
If you see a work on your dash and think, “I don’t like the subject of this work” please just make your own post or complain to your friend. But stop putting those grievances on someone’s creative work and shitting all over their good time. I would rather someone not reblog my art at all than to reblog it with a rude comment.
I think that more fanfiction should be written with the aim to tackle the original meaning of hanahaki. Because when the concept of hanahaki disease was originally created, it was intended to be a metaphor for suppressing one’s feelings.
Your feelings are this beautiful garden of flora inside of your chest. When you express how you feel honestly, you allow for it to grow freely. But when you hide how you feel out of fear of rejection, and try to make it smaller and smaller, the flowers become cramped inside of you, until you choke on your own feelings. Every flower you cough up is something you’ve felt, but refused to say.
The whole “dying” thing is intended to be more symbolic especially. You’re killing off bits and pieces of yourself and how you feel, because you’re afraid to express yourself.
It’s not really supposed to be, “The one I love doesn’t love me back, and I’m dying from it.” Rather, it’s more along the lines of, “Repressing your emotions is bad for you, and it’s better and healthier to express them freely, even when it’s scary.”
Which is to say that, one, the cure for the disease should be telling the person that you are in love with how you feel. How the other person feels about the person afflicted should have nothing to do with it, as the trope is meant to be about feeling your emotions unapologetically.
And that, two, it’s not an inherently romantic trope. Obviously, it has romantic applications, but it can be written for any situation where a character is hiding how they truly feel. This can include a refusal to address a specific trauma, a desire to indulge in something that they’re ashamed of, and even really practical things, like wanting to ask one’s boss for a higher position.
Although (as an aromantic person myself) I don’t agree with this conclusion about the trope, this application would also avoid people calling it arophobic. When the thing killing the character is a refusal to be honest with themselves, rather than an unrequited love, it’s on nobody’s hands but their own to save their life.
There are a ton of ways that this interpretation of the hanahaki disease could be applied in new and interesting ways in fanfiction, and I’d love to read what things people could come up with!
💘 It’s okay to write about toxic, unhealthy and illegal relationships in fiction.
💘 There is nothing wrong with enjoying toxic, unhealthy, or illegal relationships in fiction.
💘 Its okay even if someone accuses you of ‘romanticizing’ or ‘glorifying’ toxic, unhealthy or illegal relationships in fiction.
💘 The relationships you enjoy in fiction don’t reflect on your real life desires or your real life morals.
💘 It’s okay to enjoy toxic, unhealthy, or illegal relationships in fiction because it is fiction and not real.
baffled why so many people seem to be going after you for the Tox thing? Tox as far as i know is just a guy who appears to have done some incredibly at this point, questionable shit; still doesn’t explain the freakout over him …being on a social media site? hundreds of questionable people are on social media, literal nazis are on twitter, does that make twitter a site that only said group of people can use? no! like??? what is the logic here. tox isn’t an admin, or even staff, they’re just a person / member that happens to be a part of aethy. i’m not clicking any links i don’t recognize out of safety concerns, but if these people are so concerned about getting tox off of aethy, shouldn’t they be sending it to y’know, the actual admin or staff of aethy? why the fuck are they sending it to you?????
Fuck if I know!! I am genuinely confused about this whole ordeal! blackheartxbiohazards
I need @normal-fandom-people to know that I got into an argument with someone and lost a mutual because that mutual felt that I was slandering Tox by describing Tox as “rumored to be a toxic or abusive person.”
Meanwhile NFP is losing their mind because they think I am defending Tox.
Literally the only things I have said about Tox is that there are rumors about Tox and that Tox provably does not run Aethy.
Beyond that, I don’t know anything about the situation or what I am supposed to fucking do about it. blackheartxbiohazards