Darkfic writers “condone” writing about underage sex and incest in the same way that darkfic writers “condone” writing about murder, abuse and torture.
All fictional crimes are equally fictional.
I, a fellow writer, personally have to disagree. Killing off or harming characters is fine because they aren’t real and, as a writer you can absolutely fix it whenever you want. Underage sex and incest, as well as other sexual crimes, are sometimes written with the intent of sexual gratification of the writer or reader. Regardless of condoning those things, they are not equal in their impact the way they are in real life. It is ok to touch on those topics, but describing them in detail is risky business. And that’s coming from someone who writes about eldritch horror and mentall illness frequently.
Killing off or harming characters is also sometimes written with the intent of gratification of the writer and reader.
There is no difference.
Fiction is fiction.
Sexual gratification is no more harmful than any other emotional gratification.
Oh my god, you guys treat horniness like it’s some kind of infectious disease. Why does it fucking matter??? Why do you care if people are horny over fiction??? It’s still just fiction!!! I hate the internet.
apparently this one’s never seen a slasher movie. or guro. or nonromantic mafia glorification. i PROMISE you, gratification – even sexual gratification of an otherwise nonsexual situation – is very much OFTEN intended in depiction of violence and death. it is literally a known and exploited thing that young girls are horny over pretty anime boys covered in someone else’s blood, like you can’t just pretend that’s not a thing.
i’m all for treating death as a normal part of life, but surely we can agree that murder isn’t?? or rather, shouldn’t be! just like sexual violence shouldn’t be a normal part of life! these things are very much hand in hand.
i think if you view the two as inherently different, you should really sit yourself down and ask why, and play the devil’s advocate against all of your answers until you can’t anymore. really UNDERSTAND, don’t just go with your gut feeling.
i’ve seen a lot of these arguments, and one thing that’s very clear to me is that a lot of you on the anti side view sexual violence as “a sexual act that is violent”. but that ain’t it. it’s an act of violence that uses sex as the weapon. and as someone who’s been put through that kind of thing, i sincerely ask you to really think about the difference between those two, because it is very fucking important.
it is not the sex part that’s supposed to bother you.
if you’re bothered by the idea of someone getting off on a rape fic, but you’re not bothered by a hoard of people cheering with delight at a teenager getting torn to shreds, then it isn’t the harm that bothers you. it is specifically the sexual taboo. and i’m really sorry, but that’s a You problem, not an indication of anyone’s morality.
and to be clear, you’re not a bad person for being bothered – everyone has stuff they can’t watch. but you ARE a bad person for trying to control what other people get to enjoy and pushing your own discomfort as an indication of morality.
Which of these things should we ban because groomers use them to abuse children?
None of them.
mate you are comparing things like puppies and kindness to media involving CP and incest. these are not at all comparable. this is essentially the same sort of logic as âwell people can be killed without guns; guns don’t kill people, so why ban AR-15s?â itâs the same logic that those people use.
if you enjoy taking in media that includes CP, incest, and other things along those lines BECAUSE it has CP, incest, etc? thatâs fucked up. you cannot compare these things in the list above to that kind of media. people can use anything to do anything; it doesnât mean that some things are not inherently bad. things can be inherently bad. CP and incest are very much inherently bad. and if you cannot recognize that, you are bad.
if you enjoy partaking in media that involves CP or incest because it has CP or incest, you are bad. proshippers are bad. this isnât some âohhhohhh look at this antiâ take. no. i am the average person who isnât really a part of hardly any fandoms. and i have gone through SO much CSA. i donât care if you âuse it to copeâ and saying so doesnât absolve you of any guilt.
fuck proshippers today, tomorrow, and always.
Antis make the same arguments again and again, it’s really depressing to see.
Fiction isn’t a gun. A gun doesn’t have any use other than to harm.
Fiction is art, and art has many uses and ways to be appreciated.
You know what, letâs ignore the fact that this person is literally strawmanning the whole post for a second.
âI donât care if you use it to cope and saying so doesnât absolve you of any guiltâ Guilt for what exactly? What harm does using fictional depictions to cope do? Please feel free to enlighten me exactly how somebody using taboo themes in their private fiction, that have been written about by mainstream authors for mainstream media multiple times, for the specific reason to cope is SO bad that you feel justified in shaming and guilting your fellow survivors, that you feel a need to act so horribly to them. I would LOVE to hear it.
And by the way nobody here was arguing whether or not CSEM or CSAM were okay or good. Donât know WHERE you got that from seeing as the original post didnât even fucking imply it.