Ok, this is a little niche, but I have a theory for all you Discworld fans. Why doesnt Carrot have a beard?
A few facts to start with:
1. All Dwarves have beards.
2. Carrot is, culturally, a dwarf. He sees himself as a dwarf and other dwarfs accept him as such. (He’s just a very tall dwarf.)
So why would Carrot NOT have a beard, if all Dwarves have beards and Carrot is a dwarf? Would he choose to shave? Why? He wouldnt, right? Is there some reason he CANT grow a beard?
Another fact to remember about Disc Dwarfs:
All Dwarves are raised as men. Regardless of their biological sex and whether they are XX or XY, they are men, they use he/him pronouns, etc. (The fact that some dwarves have begun to identify and present as women is very recent in Disc history after all, and not all XX dwarves identify or present as women)
So, follow me here- the Dwarves in the mountain find a human baby. Regardless of that baby’s biological sex, they would be raised as a dwarf boy/man, yeah?
So…. may I present the theory- the reason that Carrot, a dwarf man, has no beard is because, you following, he is biologically an XX human. The fact that he cant grow a beard doesnt make him less of a dwarf man than the fact that he is 6+ feet tall.
So what I’m hearing is Carrot should be played by Gwendoline Christie
Discworld Heritage Post
Occasionally I’ll see a post I previously liked and have no memory of but I see my past enjoyment and know I’m in for a treat.
I’VE BEEN SAYING THIS!
CARROT IS TRANS FROM A HUMAN PERSPECTIVE OF GENDER.
CARROT IS AN XX CHROMOSOME PERSON WHO WOULD HAVE BEEN ASSIGNED FEMALE BY HUMANS.
just because someone is your favorite character doesnt mean theyd have the same moral alignment as you. wheatley from portal wouldnt say “my pronouns are he/him, thank you for asking!” hed say “what uhh. what does that mean. um. you mean the nouns im most "pro” at is that what youre saying? i like to think im pretty pro,, at all nouns really. umm lets see… apple, kazoo, bubble, happy, door, umm… cake. not too fond of cake really i think its alright but. not my Favorite. if it were up to me though id eat a whole cake in one sitting. if i were a human. not a human, clearly. also not sure if id, know what cake even tastes like. if i tried it. no tastebuds. no Mouth… no. hole. anywhere on my body. haha um,, well anyways id. id say im pretty Pro Nouns. dont see why anyone wouldnt be… what? you mean what i Go By? what do you. ohhhh. ummm. the male ones. the male pronouns. if i can remember what they are… definitely the ones for guys. manly men. like me. pretty sure im a man,,,“ and you need to accept this
I asked my therapist last week if she thought being proship was wrong. She didn’t know what “proship” and “anti-ship” meant, so I explained. I also told her that I kind of wanted it to be wrong, because it would make navigating the internet easier if I believed it was.
So she thinks a bit, and then goes, “Well, it’s kind of like that movie Se7en, right? It’s a good movie, but there’s a lot of really messed-up stuff in it. Watching it doesn’t mean you’re actually going to send someone a head in a box, or that the filmmakers support murder.”
Reminder that a) this person is a licensed therapist, and b) she had never even heard the term “proshipping” 10 minutes before this. She came to this conclusion totally on her own; I did not mention equating shipping to violence in fiction at all, and she came up with the same argument a lot of proshippers use regularly.
So yeah, I feel kinda validated. It’s frustrating in a way, because like I said, part of me hoped she’d say, “Actually, that sounds unhealthy and here’s why” and then give me a reason that actually made sense to me so that I was less afraid of being in certain places on the internet and maybe get some friends back. But she didn’t. So… yeah.