‼️ The only person who should have the power to decide if a piece of fiction is harming you emotionally or psychologically is you.
‼️ Any fiction you feel like you are being harmed by you can stop reading/watching/creating it at any time.
‼️ You are always in control when you are consuming or creating fiction.
‼️ Do not surrender the power to decide what fictional ideas might cause you emotional or psychological harm to other people.
‼️ No one will ever know better than you what ideas are harmful to you personally.
‼️ You cannot decide what is psychologically or emotionally harmful to another person.
‼️ Attempting to restrict the kind of fiction that people create or consume because you think it might cause them emotional or psychological harm is authoritarian.
‼️ It is safe to explore any ideas and themes in fiction. Fiction does not and cannot cause physical harm to any person. You are always in control of the fiction you are creating or consuming.
It’s true if you ignore every single stereotype of race, gender and so on that gets reinforced by *checks it* fiction.
It’s true if you ignore Fiction that is also propaganda to spread and reinforce harmful agendas (think Nazi propaganda or even closer to us, take every single piece of FICTION that reinforced that black people is either violent brutes or servants)
Fiction does not exist in a vacuum, it’s time tumblr uses take some accountability.
Yes, of course, Lord of The Rings cannot harm me, but you know who can? The Neonazis that use Tolkien race divisions to spread their beliefs, they totally can hurt me.
So does MAPS roaming around here, so does TERFS and Tradwives and Neonazis and the fiction they might have been putting out under the disguise of self expression and harmless fiction.
Fiction is only harmless as long it stays in the author’s head. Tumblr is not your diary.
Yes, of course, Lord of The Rings cannot harm me, but you know who can? The Neonazis that use Tolkien race divisions to spread their beliefs, they totally can hurt me.
So if you’re saying Tolkien is responsible for neonazis, what do you think we should do about that?
Are you saying no one should read Lord of the Rings because SOME assholes used it as inspiration for their hate?
Because if so you are basically proving my point here.
Almost nobody is gonna agree with you that Lord of the Rings is responsible for harm.
Saying FICTION is to blame for horrible things among society actually takes away accountability from the real ppl who committed atrocities.
You are literally giving the culprits an excuse for committing their crimes.
#blaming atrocities on the existence of fiction actively takes away the accountability of those who committed the atrocities#blaming it on fiction gives those people a shield to hide behind#‘target this instead so i can get away with it’ stop holding fiction accountable for the atrocities real life people committed in real life#anti culture
Chinese Censorship of the 2023 Hugo Award Nominations
Back before the 2023 Hugo Nominations were conducted, I noted that the Chengdu Worldcon Hugo committee had inserted a worrying clause indicating that local government officials could invalidate nominations for breaching the norms and standards of China. I suspected this would result in arbitrarily applied censorship to control the ballot. I am sad and unsurprised to discover I was correct.
The 2023 Hugo Nomination vote data has been published (https://www.thehugoawards.org/2024/01/2023-nominating-and-final-ballot-statistics-published/), and includes notation where nominations were excluded from the ballot. Those with normal reasons, such as being in the wrong category or not being published in 2022 are identified with their reasons for exclusion. This time there are a number of nominations that are merely marked at “Not eligible”.
Here is the list of those nominations, that would otherwise have been placed on the final 2023 Hugo Award Ballot.
Babel – R.F. Kuang – Best Novel: Very likely excluded for referencing student revolution, and the use of language and translation as coercive tools of oppression. Color the World – Congyun “Mu Ming” Hu – Best Novellette : A story about perception of, aid of, and discrimination against disability. Congyun Hu has left China and now lives in New York. Fogong Temple Padoga – Hai Ya – Best Story : Either there is something in the original Chinese that was not translated, there’s a taboo subject that elides my reading, or this otherwise innocent looking near future tale of cultural building restoration was written by the wrong person. The Art of Ghost of Tsushima: Dark Horse and Sucker Punch Games – Best Related Work : The video game Ghost of Tsushima was subject to directed social exclusion for it’s depiction of the Mongol invasion of Japan. Sandman, Amazon Studios: Best Dramatic Presentation (Long and Short) – A diverse and divergent cast, includes subject matter and social issues that are currently taboo in China. Paul Weimer – Fan Writer: Publicly Critical of holding a Worldcon in China. Xiran Jay Zhao – Astounding Award: Qualifying work “Iron Widow” is reimagined story of Chinese Empress Wu during a fantasy/mechanical alien invasion.
This raises a lot of questions as to if this basically taints the process, and what can be done about it.
It made me angrier to see that Babel had been removed from the vote than to discover that Sandman had been similarly screwed — twice, in fact: it was taken off the Long Form Drama ballot because one episode, Sandman episode 6, was getting lots of votes in Short Form Drama, and then Episode 6 was mysteriously ruled ineligible. So it didn’t go on the list of episodes you could vote for.
I’ve got a lot of Hugo Awards. But I would have loved Sandman 6 to have been allowed to compete. It would have meant the world to the people who made it.
If anyone who was part of the Chengdu Worldcon Hugo team knows what actually happened here, let me know on the ask line. Secrets will be kept. I just want to know.