–
Oh god. This topic comes around every 6 months or so. Others should feel free to help me out here, but basically…
A lot of fanfic sounds like the other fanfic and other stuff that the same communities consume. In a given era and sector of fandom, that leads to a samey style. It often has a lot of overlap with a specific sector and era of genre fiction with a heavy dose of watches-tv-does-not-read-books elements on top.
AO3 House Style is relatively similar to the height of LJ Western slash fandom. Other fanfic styles are often similar but start showing other influences the more distant you get.
There are some major strains, not always in the same works:
- Transparent genre fiction prose that doesn’t call too much attention to itself. It’s there to convey plot, not make you notice the language qua language. You’ll see something similar in, say, a Mercedes Lackey novel (along with the terrible editing and protagonist centered morality that are also common in fic, haha).
- YA boom era YA vibes.
- Kind of forced “snark” and samevoice from many characters in a way that tells you the author spent a little too much time watching Buffy.
- World building and complex thriller/mystery/etc. plots that actually work typically take a back seat to pining, angst with a happy ending, and other more ship-focused, character interaction-focused, and emotions-focused things. The general idea of a mystery, vampire AU, etc. is often present, but it’s more of a backdrop. (Depends on the part of fandom though!)
- Huge focus on the internal psychological and emotional state of characters.
- Lots of hurt/comfort, both physical and emotional.
- Lots of serialized work that shows the traces of being written that way (dangling plot threads, inflated word count, returning to similar plot points in a way that wouldn’t happen if the thing were completely written, revised, and then only posted serially).
- Certain cliched phrases like “He smelled of __ and __ and something uniquely him”, carding fingers through hair (thanks, commenters for researching this one a year or two ago and proving it’s way more common in fic!), “Oh. Oh.”, etc.
- If the fic is more self-consciously literary, it’s full of sentences that trail off to the point where you’re almost not sure what actually happened.
- Often lots of very short paragraphs and lots of scenes that are almost all dialogue
- Frequently third person limited present tense. Some third person limited past tense. Less of other stuff unless you’re looking at a fandom where canon is first person or you’re looking at readerfic (which is on AO3 but is not really “AO3 House Style”).
Honestly, some people would just say “sounds like fanfic”, but if you go read primarily on SpaceBattles or something, you’re going to find a lot of stories that don’t sound quite the same as your prototypical AO3 fic.
a gentle fact about this world is that people will want to help you. a cruel fact about it is that you do have to put on your big boy pants and open their contact on your phone and say some human words to ask them for it
– what time it is
– how long you’ve been reading
– how many chapters you’ve covered in the last 24 hours
– what you were late for because you were reading
– the woeful few hours you have left to sleep
– the emotional outbreaks you’re experiencing
– the inappropriate place you’re having said outbreak
– the general public’s reaction to your outbreak
– how much phone battery you have left
I’ve had the joy of quite a few of these comments! I love them!
I still think of the comment left on one of my fics about sneakily reading it while at a wedding
Reblogging both as a resource and as a suggestion
Gonna do a deep cut into my in-active WIPs (that I want to get back to) for this one–
Tommy Wiseau’s The Room + Oceans 11 = Vinewood Disasters 1973
Lmfao as a religious trauma survivor and a product of Christian fundie indoctrination myself I am in full support of calling fandom wank “purity culture” and the use of the word “puriteen” as well actually.
It perfectly encompasses what purity culture was. It wasn’t just about “no sex before marriage”; it policed every fucking thing you did and forced you to walk on eggshells your entire life so your Magical Sky Daddy didn’t clutch His heavenly pearls at your naughty behaviours.
Holding hands with someone you weren’t married to? Gateway to sin. Making eyes at someone of the opposite sex? Gateway to sin. Thinking “impure” thoughts about someone else?
ThoughtcrimeGateway to sin. Wearing the “wrong” type of clothes? Listening to the “wrong” kind of music? Having the “wrong” sort of values? Enjoying the “wrong” kind of media? All of it was seen as a stepping stone toward being a sinful godless heathen (and to some people it was essentially just as bad).And it wasn’t enough to just avoid BadWrong Behaviours, either. In my ex-community you were expected to express your disapproval of it and be well versed in the theological how’s and whys. Does any of that sound familiar?
Purity culture at its core is so much more than “wear this purity ring and pinky promise to Jesus that you’ll never have sex until you’re married” and if you didn’t realise that while you were there you weren’t paying attention.