I think that if you want relationships depicted in your fiction – whether primary media or fan-work – to be emotionally compelling, there’s really no getting around the fact that one of the most compelling relationship dynamics in fiction is “hey, wouldn’t it be fucked up if”.
And I don’t just mean “one of them is clearly taking advantage of the other” type relationships, either. There’s a whole spectrum of upfuckery to explore, including (but not limited to):
Each of them thinks they can fix the other, but really they’re just enabling each other’s worst impulses
Sticking together no matter what because no matter how bad they are for each other, the terror of the unknown is worse
You’re pretty sure staying in this relationship constitutes a form of wilful self-harm; for whom is genuinely unclear
They actually just straight up hate each other, but each regards the other as the only one who Gets It
They’re perfectly happy together, but the way they play off of each other is harmful to literally everyone around them
Imagine that after having a relationship with your villainous F/O, you now believe them to be dead, but–
One day, after the incident, maybe days, maybe weeks or months, you come home. Entering the room, it’s dark, but you see a silhouette in one of your chairs.
You hear a voice murmur your name.
A familiar voice.
In disbelief you turn on the light to find your villainous F/O there, having miraculously survived and made their way to you.
As you hurry to them and the two of you embrace, your F/O tells you the story of how they survived, and why they now need your help…
“One thing’s for sure… a mutant… someone who’s been hunted… someone living in a world where the air itself is poisonous… would know better than to run off into the shadows.”